Rear lights are jacked, need aftermarket suggestions

[dunkel]

Looks like the seal around my left tail light assembly has gone, as there is a lot of corrosion and rust around the area. That brake light is completely shot. So I go look over at bavauto.com and they're wanting $225 for a new assembly :
Figured for that much, or not much more, I could get something a little nicer looking, maybe. Any suggestions? It's an '86 535i, if that helps.

Thanks.