5-Series (E12,E28, E34, E39, E60)Chat relating to the BMW 5-Series of all generations. Specific models include: BMW 518, BMW 520, BMW 520i, BMW 530i, BMW 528i, BMW 530i, BMW 518i, BMW 524d, BMW 525i, BMW 525e, BMW 528e, BMW 540i, BMW 535i, BMW 520d, BMW 525td, BMW 525d, BMW 530d, BMW 525i/xi, BMW 530i/xi. (BMW 5-Series Forum)
'99 540i Do I need a new Tranny, or another Mechanic?
Here are the symptoms my 5401 (1999 with 174K Miles) has just started entertaining me with lately. In this case, the car has a rumble emanating from what seems to be the rear passenger side to the driver, but of course sounds more like rear driver side to the front seat passenger. Low pitched rumble but high frequency, like those warning strips on some highways when you run on the shoulder. Actually one of my ride-along ace mechanics thinks its funny that it makes the same exact noise his son makes blowing through his lips to make airplane/car "motorboat" noises when at play. To me, not so funny. So far, BMW dealers have said, basically, "Gimme $6,000.00 for a new trans and the noise will go away, most likely." Two indies have said, "Gimme $4,000.00 for a rebuilt tranny and the noise will PROBABLY go away" yet another expert has said "Give us $750.00 to put in a new control valve assembly and it's 50% sure the noise will go away" , and that same helpful soul has also said "If its not the control valve assembly, then you need a new torque converter for only another $400.00 from us, and that should fix it, but we'll have to charge you $500.00 to install it." I'm sensing a pattern here, and not a very good one. Problem I have with all the assembled experts is that not one of them has any difficulty prescribing these $400.00 to $6,000.00 fixes, but when I asked each one directly if they would do the work and guarantee the problem got solved or refund my money, each and every one said, in a word, "No Way!" This after my paying them for the exams, of course. Meanwhile, my treasured 540 goes along making a "motorboat" noise somewhere in the rear that reverberates all through the inside of the car for 30 seconds of every few minutes I drive it at 45 to 55 mph in either Drive, 4th, or 3rd gears, which is of course driving me crazy and causing any passengers to wonder what is wrong with the car for doing this and me for driving it. When this noise/vibration occurs, the engine drops a 100 rpm or so, as if under added load, and the condition will stop immediately if you accelerate or slow down just a bit. Of course once you return to the dreaded 45-55 mph speed range, the whole cycle repeats again, and again, and again, until you stop and get out of the car in order to shout at it. Anyone out there had this happen with your cars, and if so can you tell me what's really going on and what will ACTUALLY fix it? Needless to say, I'm inclined to try the less ghastly expensive fixes first, but if the incremental fixes don't get the job dine, I get to spend LOTS of cash and still keep the vibration, while the lady of the house gets to let me know just how stunningly bright I was not to go for the big bucks first and be done with it, PROBABLY. Any help, anyone?
if your tranny is faulty the car will not accelerate or select properly but then again its a 540 v8 (M62) my guess will be the rear differencial try looking it up and check the wheel bearings too while you are at it because i once had an issue with my 535i v8 (M62) when the front left wheel bearing started acting up the noice was terrible when i speed up and stop when i slow down.
I did have a similar issue but a different noise and no vibration (more of wind droning issue than a motor boat, and at lower speed (60km/h 35-50mph) in top under very light load, droning noise and slight drop in rpm and speed). I chased it around thinking it was the Intake rear manifold cover, did find some vacuum leaks in the process, but eventually i put the car in for a transmission fluid change at a auto specialist shop. They did the oil change properly (drained torque converter as well as the pan), changed the filter, ran diags on the gear box, all came up clear, oil was dirty, no metal (no more than normal) in the old oil, all good. They said that the issue was probably engine management or electricals, but once driving the issues had disappeared. All the for the price of the service, fluids and filter, $250.
My point is it may or may not be the fluids or filter, but its a quick diagnostics effort and it doesn't take you off the road for long, and if the car has been serviced according to the BMW manual, the ATF has never been changed. Good luck.
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.