OK this just took a turn for the worse. It turns out the key cylinder was busted out on the passenger side and the owners manual (which had my registration and old insurance cards in it) was stolen as well. In order for them to have gotten all the windows open, they would have had to attempt to start the car. I know the remote key needs to be used to start it (which would explain why I still have a car), but how did they get the power on?
Now I'm screwed - do I get new locks all around? Just replace the one that was ripped out? Now some jackass low life is running around with my owners manual and my address.