3-Series (E46, E90)Chat relating to the BMW 3-Series from 1999 to Current. Models include: BMW 316i, BMW 318i, BMW 318Ci, BMW 320i, BMW 323i, BMW 325i, BMW 330i, BMW 328 Ci, BMW 328i, BMW 325i/xi, BMW 330Ci, BMW 320d, BMW 330d, BMW 335d.
Which has faster acceleration? I know that when in steptronic mode...the vehicle is in "Sport" mode...and steptronic is manual...but switching gears isn't the same thing as a true manual....which I personally think is better and more fun....but that's beside the point.
If there is a difference....how much a difference? Would I be able to tell?
Any thoughts....or help in this situation would be most appreciated....
My understanding is that a steptronic transmission takes out the clutch part of the clutch->shift->gas equasion. Being as such, the steptronic could be considered fractions of a second faster than a standard tranny. Since an automatic is generally slower in it's gearing and shifting than a manual, the steptronic would be faster...
Though I've never had a steptronic (that came after my model year) and I could be wrong.
__________________ <img src='http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v298/doughboyea/car3.jpg' border='0' alt='user posted image' />
<span style='color:green'><u>Proud</u> Member of the BMW Community</span>
<span style='color:black'>1999 BMW 328i Jet Black --Total Dinan Points: 5 --
<a href='http://dinancars.com/SeriesPrint.asp?prod=335' target='_blank'>----</a>Dinan Stage 1 Suspension<a href='http://dinancars.com/SeriesPrint.asp?prod=335' target='_blank'>----</a></span>
<span style='color:black'><a href='http://www.ajusa.com/cgi-bin/knfilters/start?r=ajusa&ajr_skey=e2398f2ee8c6388757f9e7fb800 a4cb9' target='_blank'> --</a>K&N Air Filter<a href='http://www.ajusa.com/cgi-bin/knfilters/start?r=ajusa&ajr_skey=e2398f2ee8c6388757f9e7fb800 a4cb9' target='_blank'> --</a></span>
Today I tested the acceleration of a 2004 325i....and I was messing around with the steptronic...it had me confused....at which RPMs or speed do I switch gears...since it had me mind-boggled....I didn't mess with it anymore...
Then....I tried testing out the acceleration of the automatic.....it seemed good to me....but obviously not good enough for the guy next to me....so I was really wondering if I were "good" and knew a liitle bit more about how to use the steptronic...would I have been able to beat him?
I was seriously disappointed in the steptronic. I tested it in both automatic and step mode (328i) and auto was ok. The first time I tried it in step the car was in first and about to redline, I was about to shift up and the car did it for me. I was a little confused, so I had my foot to the floor and the thing did the same in second. it would not hit the red line. So I did an experiment. Starting again with my foot to the floor in first (still using step) I tried to short shift into second at around 4000 rpm, keeping my foot firmly to the floor. The car continued and shifted at around 6000, totally ignoring me. After a few more similar tests I came to the conclusion that the auto steptronic is a load of bollocks, and bought the manual, which when driven correctly is a good second or more quicker to 60mph.
Hmmmmm thanks for the advice...I'll give it a try on out when I get a chance....I hope it is different for the 04 325i.....is 4000 rpm a good time to swich gears for any gear whether in step or manual?
Originally posted by BMWLotAttendant@Aug 25 2004, 10:48 AM Hmmmmm thanks for the advice...I'll give it a try on out when I get a chance....I hope it is different for the 04 325i.....is 4000 rpm a good time to swich gears for any gear whether in step or manual?
It all depends, 4000 is not necessarily a good time to change, but depends on the road conditions. The point is if the steptronic is going to override you what is the point? May as well just use auto.
Steptronic is still an automatic tranny on the inside, just with a "manual" shift mode. It is not a manual tranny with an automatic shifter. Big difference if you know anything about trannys. A manual has an actual cog for each gear ratio, a real gear engaged with another real gear, whereas an auto uses planetary gear sets engaged by fluid clutch packs. An auto is connected to the crankshaft by the torque converter which is a fluid connection, instead of being mechanically connected via a clutch and pressure plate like the manual. A manual will always be better, unless you just don't like shifting gears. Using steptronic is no different than pulling any other automatic shifter down into 1 and manually pushing it up into 2, 3, then D when you want it to shift, which of course it only does if it feels like it, just like Steptronic.
not to mention the parasitic hp loss due to moving around that heavy fluid, and the added 50 kg that an automatic weighs, the standards should always be faster....and dont get me started about SMG...grrr
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.