There have been a few times lately when I turn the key to start the car, but it doesn't turn over at all. If you turn the key back to the off position, and then try to start it again, it starts up like it should.
Is there a relay or something that could be starting to go bad? I'd rather replace it now, rather then wait until it completely fails, and am unable to start the car.
Originally posted by El Presidente@Aug 15 2004, 11:45 PM Mine does what you describe. Mostly when it is very hot or right after a short trip.
The anwer is a new starter. Mine has been doing for years and still doesn't need a replacement, as it is very rare. It actually hasn't done it much at all lately. Its been months.
The point: Spend $200 if you really want, but it may be a temp fluke that doesn't need addressing just yet.
And by yet I mean years.
200 bucks for the starter? Hell man, i ll tell ya what, I live in NYC, If my starter goes I will fly you in to NYC, put you up for the night at a hotel , pay the 200 bucks for the starter and you do the work. Unlike most cars, the starter on the 325's require you to remove the intake manifold (at least from what the mauals say, althoughif anyone has done this swap without pulling the manifold please let me know only for 325's with the I6 engine). Since I have just pulled this manifold recently i can tell you that it is a pain in the neck and you should plan on about 12 hours if you have never done it, and another 100 bucks in miscellaneous parts like vacuum hoses you will want to replace while you have the manifold off, the fitting for the ICV which you will almost certainly break, the 6 gaskets that go between the manifold and the head (10 bucks each from the stealer and yes if your car is more than 3-4 years old or more than 30-40K miles you will need to replace them, lest you get to do the job all over again when you find out the old ones leak!!!) Oh yeah you should also buy 2 extra nuts with built in washers that hold the manifold to the head.... the back one is a bit of a bitch to get to and you will drop it a couple of times before you finally get it started. Make no mistake changing the starter is not a DIY job for those with limited experiance. the potential for screwing something up is pretty big, if you dont have a good game plan, and are not systematic in your removal of parts (and using little baggies t store and mark which nuts bolts washers etc came from where.
Originally posted by El Presidente@Aug 16 2004, 12:24 PM glad I don't drive an i6.
Replacing the starter on the i4 is quite simple as acess is not restricted much at all. I also recall seeing a writeup on reomving the starter from below. I'll see if I can find it.
If you can find that write up that would be most excellent. I am going by the Chilton manual that says remove the intake manifold. I would personally at least try getting it from underneath even if it ment cutting one of the bolts and replacing it from the opposite side.
My car runs w/o the key in it...For the past 6 months when i put my key into the ignition, it turns, and turns, and turns w/o starting. After turning it a couple times it finally works. And today when i was trying to turn the car off, the key came out but the car was still on! It was scary, felt like my car was possessed or something. Anywhoo~ i went to the dealership and he said that it would cost me about 800 bucks to fix it. So...any suggestions on what i should do? I can take it to non-dealerships to fix, but it's night now, and I want to know what other options i'll have, maybe i can fix it?!?! hehe...So help me out w/ your suggestions...Thanks!
OH...btw, my car is a 318ti 1996.
For now since it wouldn't turn off, i took the engine fuse or something like that off and unplugged the battery from the car. Probably won't be able to turn it on again until the starter's fixed huh?
Where do you live? Somewhere in CA? I live in Santa Barbara, so if you could help out, I'd pay!!! =) please call if you can on my cell phone (415-867-6447). My name's Janet. I'll be awake for a while so up to 1AM is fine =) thanks!!!
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.