| well after carefull study, I have a question, does the white one have xenons?
Id say, the 8000miles left of warrantyin the Red one arent worth it at that point, whetever problem it has the dealer theoretically has to deal with it first, Id have it checked by a mechanic....
But go for the white one...looks wise, its a lot tighter, but tell the dealer, that you would like to see what can be done about the chis and scratches....they have ways....
If they actually agree to deal with the paint...tell them to paint the bumper in the same pattern as mine...check the sig.... you will not regret it...
GO FOR THE WHITE!!!!
make sure you have a good mechanic that can deal with them, and have a great time!!!
__________________ <img src='http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v129/EVeRcyCLinG/newcarpics/BMWsignature.jpg' border='0' alt='user posted image' /> | 
